Why do some
literary characters stick around in our consciousness? Take for example, Boo
Radley and the characters from To Kill a Mockingbird (Harper Lee’s only novel
by the way). And then there is the character of Lenny in John Steinbeck’s Of
Mice and Men, Huck Finn and Tom Sawyer from Mark Twain, Ahab’s obsession with
Moby Dick by Melville, and Hester Prynne from Nathaniel Hawthorne’s Scarlet
Letter. There are many other
characters that simply haunt us, not because they’re particularly unique, but
precisely because each of them invites us in to a deeper knowledge of the human
condition. And I dare say that each character understands the depths of human
poverty very well.
I believe that
is why Shakespeare is still performed, parodied, and praised hundreds of years
after his death. Because Shakespeare, whether it is Hamlet’s suicidal soliloquy
questioning his own futility through asking simply, ‘to be or not to be,’ or
whether it is Jacques’ closing announcement in As You Like It, that all the
world is a stage and the men and women are merely players. And it’s the killers
who pause in Richard III telling one another that the conscience does make
cowards of us all.
These
characters, novels, and plays help us to enter more fully in to the human
condition and in to human poverty. These characters also all referred to the
Bible at some point in their own stories. Sherlock Holmes is no exception and I
want to make the case today that the world’s greatest detective is also useful
for us in understanding the human condition, global poverty, and if we pay
attention, we will begin to look for clues that will lead us ever closer to an
understanding of grace.
Sherlock
Holmes is Aware of His own Shortcomings
I don’t know
what image you have of Sherlock Holmes, but let me destroy a few of them if I
can. First, the hat (a deerstalker cap by name) is never mentioned in any of
the stories by Doyle himself, instead the hat is a creation by illustrator
Sidney Paget (who is an interesting story himself, the magazine thought they
were getting his very talented and more well known brother) and only appears in
8 of the 38 drawings that Paget did for Strand magazine.
Secondly, the
pipe mentioned in the Holmes’ stories is a straight, long-stem cherrywood
piece, the curved step, with the rather large bowl, was an invention of
playwright and theatre director William Gillette who staged one of the first
Sherlock Holmes plays in England.
Thirdly, never
in any of the 56 stories or 4 novels that Sir Arthur Conan Doyle wrote, did
Holmes ever say, ‘Elementary, my dear Watson.’
So, if your
image of Holmes fits the cap wearing, curved pipe smoking detective, who utters
‘elementary my dear Watson,’ at the end of an adventure, then you’re wrong or
at least you’ve accepted an image of Holmes that simply isn’t depicted in any
of the original stories.
Instead, listen
to Sherlock Holmes describe himself in the first novel, A Study in Scarlet. This is also the first time that Dr.
Watson ever meets Sherlock Holmes. Holmes is describing himself to Watson and
suggesting that together they buy an open flat at 221 B Baker Street that has
just opened up and is now listed at an affordable price.
“You don’t mind
the smell of strong tobacco, I hope? I generally have chemicals about, and
occasionally do experiments. Would that annoy you? I get in the dumps at times,
and don’t open my mouth for days on end. You must not think I am sulky when I
do that. Just let me alone and I’ll soon be all right (we find out later that
he is also addicted to cocaine, stays up most of the night reading and running
experiments, and plays the violin to relieve stress).”
Quite the
roommate….but also, quite self-aware. He simply tells Watson of all of these
shortcomings and says very clearly that he is difficult to live with, but would
enjoy the company if Watson would enjoy his. All of this on the first meeting.
In the Red
Headed League, the third story Doyle wrote, Watson goes to Holmes and asks him
what he is going to do about the perplexing clues that have been presented to
them. Sherlock Holmes replies with these words:
“I am going to
smoke. It is quite a three pipe problem and I beg that you won’t speak to me
for the next fifty minutes.”
In the novel,
The Sign of Four, Doyle opens up the story with this striking exchange between
Holmes and Watson:
continue reading