Last week, a long-running smear campaign
against "spiritual formation" at Biola University kicked it up a notch. An
organization called Lighthouse Trails teamed up with Apprising
Ministries to unleash a torrent of criticism and insults about Biola,
claiming that Biola is drifting from its strong biblical roots and
embracing "apostate Roman Catholic mystical spiritual formation"…
I haven't the energy to summarize the smears, but if you want to follow it thus far, read the following posts:
Biola University Now Drifting from Evangelical Protestant Roots? (Oct 20)
Biola University Student Reports on Contemplative Chapel Services - Warns Parents to Avoid Biola (Oct 20)
Biola University Contacts Lighthouse Trails – Accuses of Libel (Oct 21)
You'll be shocked when you find out just what it is that these
people are up in arms about… Contemplative prayer! That's right, they
are worried about Biola possibly being apostate because in chapel we
dare to introduce students to ancient methods of contemplative,
meditative prayer. We dare to engage the students in Lectio Divina, an
ancient method inherited from the Desert Fathers of deeply reading and
meditating upon a scripture. It's not new-agey or mystical; it's
simple, quiet, and meaningful. The bible takes center stage. What is
wrong with that?
Evidently these critics of Biola are worried that by having an
entire chapel service of silent meditation, there is somehow a movement
of apostasy being birthed in the students' minds. It's wrong, they
suggest, to have a scripture read without a pastor or speaker there to
unpack it and give it some context.
Todd Pickett, Associate Dean of Spiritual Development at Biola, has
a different opinion. He believes that students today are
"over-messaged" and need more time to just contemplate what they've
already been hearing, learning, experiencing in Christ.
"I hear from students that they need more time for processing and
reflection," he told The Chimes, Biola's student newspaper. "They feel
overwhelmed sometimes by the amount of information that comes at them.
That makes sense to me, [and] at the very least, we need to allow a
little time and a little room to listen to what God is doing. [We need
to] take some of the things we hear and talk to God about them. I am
trying to build that into the rhythm of chapel."
As someone who was a busy college student myself not too long ago,
I resonate with every word of what Pickett is saying. Time for
reflection is the number one need of students today.
Apparently
the folks at Lighthouse Trails and Apprising Ministries don't agree,
however. To them, Pickett, along with people like Richard Foster (who
they label "neo-Gnostic"), Henri Nouwen, and Dallas Willard (who, for
the record, gave a very philosophical and helpful lecture at Biola's
Torrey Conference last Wednesday), represent an unbiblical mysticism that
masquerades as "spiritual formation."
It baffles me that "spiritual formation," which to me looks like a
positive, healthy thing from every angle, is being so aggressively
criticized. Even more baffled that Biola is being singled out and
smeared for their commitment to it. But then again, Christians tend to
be the most critical of all people, unfortunately. So I guess it
shouldn't surprise me.
Note: These comments in no way represent the official position of
Biola University. This is a personal blog and all content and ideas
submitted by Brett McCracken are his own and not necessarily that of
Biola.
EMAIL THIS PAGE
PRINT
RSS
Comments
How incredibly bizarre and ethnocentric that all is.
I am agreed with you.
Mobile Spy Software
I don't. crafts
I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog, I will keep visiting this blog very often.dentist in houston
It amazes me how things are different across the world. I guess it makes you realize that you should be happy for the country that you live it - I know I sure am.
vxpqjcf
I love how the site was presented. Yeah, ultrasound technician schools even though many will be against movements against a spiritual cause, but if we have God always by our side, I'm sure we can overcome any obstacles.
thanks great opinion in pulauweb web hosting murah indonesia and
Voucher Hotel Murah di RajaKamar.Com go for number one
It is so bizarre!
Universal Studios Magic Shop
It was supposed to happened earlier. Best WP Plugins
So, when it is going to be implemented?
internet dating
It is of course nice review about the application. It contains truly information. Your website is very useful. Thanks for sharing. Looking forward to more!Personal loans
its really very sad to hear. Webmaster Blog|Eiweißpulver|download|Seo Blog
This is very informative and helpful. Please notify me if you any update!
Great stuff here. The information and the detail were just perfect. I think that your perspective is deep, its just well thought out and really fantastic to see someone who knows how to put these thoughts down so well. Great job on this.san antonio dental
Nice post. I learn something more challenging on different blogs every day. It will always be stimulating to read content from other writers and practice a little something from their store. penny stock brokers
I find this informative just like ultrasound technician salary. I might agree though it is incredibly bizarre, I hope to see more regarding this blog in the future.
I love how the site was presented. Yeah, even though many will be against movements against a spiritual cause, but if we have God always by our side, I'm sure we can overcome any obstacles.
This is a good post. Can really helped a lot especially if this will be recommended to others. ultrasound technician
As formal chapel chair at Biola, I too do not have the strength to go into detail as to why these articles are so ridiculous and narrow-minded. Biola and many Christian Universities need prayers and wise, engaging leaders like Todd Picket, Barry Correy, and Craig Detweiler. My utmost faith is in them and those who challenge others to think more like Christ in today's culture.
lameixisolsw bhd multiplying scientific notation fd home improvement complete series
reat stuff here. The information and the detail were just perfect. I think that your perspective is deep, its just well thought out and really fantastic to see someone who knows how to put these thoughts down so well. Great job on this erbesbuch df puterecom sg pasimalir sdh delaserug
Thanks a lot its fine fabric to read simple things the following posting heightens this awareness pretty beneficial for the individuals all those who would like to find something to help fine around her everyday living.
NH Weddings
This is a great inspiring article. I am pretty much pleased with your good work. You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. essays and term papers writing
updseupn
Wow. Who knew that being "contemplative" was such a bad thing?
It sounds like some of these organizations need to get a global perspective on some of the ACTUAL problems facing our world right now.
Kristen
It's unbelievable: the amount of information that this organization materializes based solely on letters and communication by ONE ANONYMOUS STUDENT'S opinion. It's underhanded of them to sneakily use a covert "snitch" for information, and it's also ridiculous that this (possibly grudge-harboring?) student won't stand behind his/her claims with open identity. It's doubtful that the student even considered going into Dr. Pickett's office and discussing these ideas openly and maturely. One word: shameful.
Biola should be proud to be associated with other individuals and ministries these two organizations are vilifying: Dallas Willard, Rick Warren, and Dallas Theological Seminary are just three that I found. The best way to handle these kinds of attacks is to ignore the people who launch them.
I don't know anything about the specific situation at Biola, but this article is relevant and helpful, imo.
"Why Evangelicals Are Returning to Rome"
http://cicministry.org/commentary/issue105.htm
I was surprised by the spending of influence by those listed? In actuality I would have expected it because all are interested in getting what they wanted never mind the consequences. Very useful for me I will bookmark this for my future needed. thanks for a great source.san antonio dentists
I say this as someone who taught at Biola and who briefly helped at his church with their spiritual disciplines program.
I have to politely disagree with each of the commenters so far. I don't think you should point the finger back at Lighthouse Trails or Apprising Ministries so quickly, call them ethnocentric, decry their perspective, or shrug it off. I think you should hear the criticism more constructively. Hear their concerns or forewarning, see if there's a kernal of Biblical truth in there, and then adjust appropriately.
You said, "spiritual formation, to me, looks like a positive, healthy thing from every angle...". Your angle is as a former college student who attended and now works at Biola. The angle you're coming from might not be informed from this other perspective.
It seems to me Lighthouse and Apprising's error might be in lumping spiritual disciplines into a "contemplative" category. You can't write off all spiritual disciplines because of a few bad apples - but we should hear what those apples look, sound, and taste like. Their concern seems to be that emphasizing the contemplative opens the door to error, and I think they have a point there. Merton blended Buddhism with this faith and practices. The biggest name in the emerging church, who has led his congregation in these practices during sermons, attended an interfaith conference this past year and made no reference at all to Jesus and called the Dalai Lama "His Holiness". It's not prudent to write off the criticism as some crazies with no point.
All that to say, are spiritual disciplines inherently bad? Nope. Should we gauge them and their use by the authority of the Bible? Yes. Should quiet time or contemplative prayer take the place of preaching? Not at all.
In Acts, did the apostles go around teaching people contemplative prayer? Did the new converts devote themselves to contemplative prayer? (Acts 2) No, the apostles preached and taught the Gospel, and that's what the people devoted themselves to - that should be the priority in a chapel or church service.
This is my first time I visit here. I found so many interesting stuffs in your blog especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the enjoyment here! Keep up the good work.It is really a matter of spirit of individual how and when they will pray to the GOD.
Numerous many thanks for taking this prospect to speak about this, I really feel strongly about this and I get satisfaction in discovering out about this make a difference.
making money on the internet
Thank you for posting this, Nick. A friend sent me this link ( which I have never visited before ) because I recently shared a concern with her about a college professor here at a Christian college in Northern California that is requiring her English 101 students ( my daughter being one of them ) to read Thomas Merton`s New Seeds of Contemplation. Because of several things this professor said to her students, as well as a concern I had about the first book that was required reading in the class, I decided that I needed to read the book myself as well as do research on just who Thomas Merton is/was. The first two chapters in NSOC concerning contemplation I do find disturbing, but even more disturbing is the research and quotes I found about Thomas Merton himself and his connections with Eastern mystics including the Dalai Lama as you state above. If a person does research they will find that TM was steeped into Eastern mysticism. I realize that the author of this site claims that Biola`s contemplative prayer focuses on scripture which I would not disagree with at all, but I would like to know if someone would be able to share with us the process ( is there one? )in which the students apply/do contemplative prayer at Biola? I also feel it is a "good thing" to consider accusations that come against any of us that may be Christian leaders or teachers because we all are fallible, and although some accuse to be contentious, others are genuinely concerned.
Warmly,
Nanette Fenn
Thanks Nick for your voice of dissent. I do think that we should see their perspective and appreciate it. But to set the record straight: I do work at Biola but I did not attend here as a student. I went to Wheaton College for undergrad and UCLA for grad school. And lest it be assumed that I'm totally on the side of the spiritual formation movement and all that goes along with it, I should point out that I have been vocally distant from the emerging church movement for many years (see this and this, among others), and have been anything but shy about my affinity for Reformed theology.
So it's not like I'm an insider apologist for this whole spiritual formation movement. I'm just looking at it and wondering what all the worry and skepticism is about.
Well, it looks like they've latched onto your past as further proof of Biola's descent into apostacy.
http://apprising.org/2008/10/managing-editor-for-biola-magazine-confirms...
I've got to say that my biggest distress is the haste with which they lump any and everything together, with little regard to justification of their claims, in order to build their case. Also, the quick dismissal of the Roman Catholic Church is more then just a little uncharitable, don't you think?
As formal chapel chair at Biola, I too do not have the strength to go into detail as to why these articles are so ridiculous and narrow-minded. Biola and many Christian Universities need prayers and wise, engaging leaders like Todd Picket, Barry Correy, and Craig Detweiler. My utmost faith is in them and those who challenge others to think more like Christ in today's culture.
Over the next fifty years we might see the long decline of Christianity in this country, but even if there are two Christians left in this country, at least one of them will be publishing prodigious content online.
Thank you for this blog! I now know what I was introduced to and troubled by at a "spiritual retreat" several years ago. Nick gave wise advice.
the point of this blog was not to warn people of the "dangers" of spiritual formation.
It wasn't????
Yeah, I know, I got that. But it did provide me with the specific terms so I can research these practices. I'm not offering an opinion on what is or is not going on at Biola; I do have a definite opinion about what I was exposed to at that retreat.
The critics of Biola may be overreacting, I really have no clue, but it never hurts (and often is beneficial!) to evaluate criticism carefully and honestly examine whether any of the expressed concern is valid. The kneejerk reaction of dismissing any and all criticism or word of caution puts you on the exact same level as the ones who pronounce judgement without all the facts.
You're right but my response was not a kneejerk reaction. I read all the articles and know the details of Biola's theology and practices which allowed me to come to a reasonable, researched, conclusion.
I'm sorry, CJ, that "you" was not directed specifically at YOU -- I was reacting to the tenor of the blog itself and of several of the responses. Should have been clearer.
Rob,
Could you edit a bit and say something a little less offensive with the "grow" comments. There are other terms you could use in Christian charity, right?
"Seriously? You didn't make it through all of the unfounded, unjustified and unproven attacks on Biola's students, chapels, staff, and faculty? All you could think of was that darn "spiritual retreat" when they asked you to go into quiet time with the Word, leaving your inattentive boredom to drive you to a state of mild discomfort (OH NO HERESY, BAHHH!!). Okay, perhaps that's not exactly what happened, but to read through these blogs and articles and say "Hmm... this is good stuff" is like having a drug dealer give you two bucks while you respond with "Hmm.. what a nice man." "
Wow, Rob, was that directed at me? If so, would you mind please explaining exactly what it was I said that set you off?
This sort of back and forth nonsense is exactly what the Apprising fellas love to stoke. I say let them piss and moan on their website and pay them no mind. Let them have fun with their picket signs and minor-prophet-wanna leader. The "Spiritual Formation" degree is the best thing Biola's got going!
This is one of the good articles you can find in the net explaining everything in detail regarding the topic. I thank you for taking your time sharing your thoughts and ideas to a lot of readers out there.
-sell house at auction
When you say "what's wrong with that?", I hope you are really interested to hear a reasoned answer to that question. The problem is that the term "contemplative prayer" actually has three different definitions poured into the term. One definition, the one you are defending, does seem good. The problem is that the other two definitions are problematic. See my analysis at http://www.chooseyourbeliefs.com/2009/03/many-definitions-of-contemplati... .
By the way, I am attending the Spiritual Formation conference at Wheaton today, which is why I ended up seeing your blog. One of the papers being presented is "Centering Prayer: the good, the bad and the ugly, from the chair of Christian formation at Wheaton.
I was looking for the document "Sanctification in a New Key: Relieving Evangelical Anxieties Over Spiritual Formation" in preparation for the conference, which is why I ran across your blog this morning.
The best way to avoid smearing, from either side of a debate, is to address the specific issues raised and to make sure we are all using the same definitions of the terms we are discussing.
Lowell Ballard
hey !!!!!!!!Congrats to the Mystic sects who after many decades of trying to bring their occult practices into the mainstream organic face church, have finally found a generation who considers everything "spiritual" good, and testing the spirits offensive. Calling "transcendental meditation" skin studio "contemplative prayer" to make it sound good, is like calling a "starved lion" a "fluffy bunny" to make it sound cuddly. So many heresies and false religions have come out of these shea butter trance states that evil spirits consider a playground.
I am an ultrasound technician and love what you said in this post. I am quite impressed with your fresh information. Thank you a lot!