EMAIL THIS PAGE       PRINT       RSS      

Rockstar

Lately I have been thinking about the role that the pastor plays. It seems that often times, we as pastors strive for the glorified, upfront position in which we are essentially the lead singer of a rock band. We seek to make a name for ourselves by fighting the battles and then coasting into our prime ministry years after making a name for ourselves by paying our dues playing in the smaller clubs and venues, before making it to the big stage.

This view of pastoral ministry has left me with quite a disgusted feeling inside. I am essentially performing to a certain level to entertain a certain crowd in order to achieve a certain level of achievement. How is this different from entertainment. A man by the name of Marshall McLuhan about thirty some years ago made a now famous statement saying “the medium is the message.” By making this statement he was essentially saying that what we communicate by what we do is making as much or more of a statement than what we are actually saying in our words. In other words, by performing to a certain level, attaining this rockstar status, we are in essence proclaiming that a pastor is a celebrity of sorts.


Mike Pilavacci when he spoke at our church a couple months ago made a statement similar to this. In one of his sermons, he spoke of himself beginning to think of himself at one point in his career as a “minor Christian celebrity” because of how he was becoming known. At this point in the message he proceeded to turn it around and talk about how meaningless and worthless this prestige is.

It is interesting to ponder what Jesus thinks of rockstar pastors. Does he become glad that some use his name to gain personal fame? Is he thrilled when we make it to the big time?

Didn’t he just seem thrilled with the religious leaders of his day who seemed puffed up with themselves? Didn’t he just love it when they prayed on the street corners and paraded around showing off their vast amounts of wisdom and superiority?

Why did Jesus say that some would say “Lord, Lord” but he would say to them “I never knew you.”? Are there some among us that are saying “Lord, Lord” but who do not have the right motives?

In a rock band, it is the lead singer and/or lead guitar player who get all of the girls. They are usually the showmen of the band. Meanwhile, the rhythm guitar, bass, and drums sit back and do most of the work, and less show, receiving much less glory. Many of us strive to be in this pastoral position of leadsinger/rockstar, calling the shots and getting the glory and credit. This is far different from Jesus whom did not call us to stardom but self-denial and self-death. Are we ready to put others before ourselves and lead as Jesus did or is our glory more important than that of the one whom we claim to serve?

 

Phil

Comments

Phil,

I totally agree with you. There are pastors out there that perpetuate this cycle by believing that they are only there to preach then leave before the service is over and retreat to a place where they can recoup. I understand that sometimes that even Jesus needed to retreat at times, but this has become a common occurence with pastors, especially of mega-churches. If we as pastors become to busy to talk with the people we are shepherding, I believe we have lost the idea of what we are supposed to do. We hole ourselves up to prepare messages and then do not stick around to see the Holy Spirit work through the people listening. I know this is an age old pastor saying, but what if we taught from the overflow of what our lives in Christ are? I like to think that that overflow would also be the energy that I needed to talk with the people that may just need to know that someone, even a pastor cares for them. Just my thoughts...

Strength and Honor,
E

i agree that what we do makes more of a statement than our words do. for bands to play a set and then take off devalues the church and those in it. to live a life contrary to the words in the songs we sing is a slap in the face to the very work that a worship leader claims to be trying to accomplish.

my speculation is that most worship leaders who are now famous once started innocently enough, but were propelled into stardom far beyond their expectations, and got addicted to the stardom, forgetting what they were all about. now they justify their lives with christian jargon that is empty and fruitless.

but i don't know if fighting the 'christian celebrity' syndrome is the answer. i think if you can influence a greater number of people with a great gift in music, and you are a person of integrity who lives a life that honors Jesus, that could be a very positive thing for the Kingdom. the problem is that the influence that a christian artist has is over people who are primarily already christian. that doesn't really hit the nail on the head. Jesus was hard on the religious and compassionate to the lost and hurting, spending most of his time with them.

a solution i'm think of is if the person who is a great christian leader was willing to take on the challenge of putting themselves in a position of influence that was primarily affecting people who didn't believe in Jesus. i'm thinking of positions like news anchors, talk show hosts, bands, political leaders... what if the people who strive for church jobs and prestige within them would change their actions to strive for jobs where their faith could influence the world, rather than the church?

mind you this is not THE solution, just an idea that sparked from reading phil's blog.

Jason,

I like your post, but I have a question regarding one of your last statements...
Do people that strive for church jobs for the prestige within them really belong in the church? I agree that this is happening and I wonder why? My first thought is that some view their position in the church as safe because they are surrounded by others that basically believe the same thing they do and their faith tends to become stagnant because they are not putting themselves in a position where they can be challenged and exercise their faith. Just my thoughts...

»  Become a Fan or Friend of this Blogger
About
Phil is a pastor and Ph.D. student (studying the relationship between media/new media and theology). He also creates music in his home studio. This blog is about media, church, theology, music, society, and other ramblings.


Media