EMAIL THIS PAGE       PRINT       RSS      

Troy Davis & The New Jim Crow: It Could've Been Me

As I sit here stunned and a bit silenced, I’m befounded by the decision to murder a man with no physical evidence, witnesses who recant their testimony, another shooter identified, and a pile of evidence pointing to doubt in the murder of an off duty police officer, Mark MacPhail. If you are unfamiliar with what has been happening here, then simply type in Troy Davis into any search engine and read up on the facts. Kevin Powell, Lisa Guerrero have written some amazing pieces and Jasiri X has had an amazing push for the stay of execution for Troy Davis that you can read as well.


My problem here is twofold: 1) the lack of justice for African Americans—in particular—in this country (this is a historical problem; if you are new to this I highly recommend taking an African American history class ASAP) and what the life of one young Black male is worth in this country of ours. 2) What is the response of the Christian community in the face of death? Christians—particularly conservatives—will argue until the day is done that there is a “right to life.” But what life? And what about those who are innocent but have been accused of a crime they didn’t commit? Do we stand silent in that? How do the politics of race come into play in these issues?

Therefore, I am reminded of Howard Thurman’s question for Christians who are impotent to act in the face of racial, class, and social injustices: “Is it the impotency due to a betrayal of the genius of the religion, or is it due to a basic weakness in the religion itself” (Jesus and the Disinherited preface)? My prayer is that it is just the betrayal.

What we have here is an extreme injustice. As Kevin Powell so eloquently pointed out, in the brutal murder of Oscar Grant by a White police officer—who was caught on tape indecently, shooting Grant in cold blood while handcuffed—gets less than 2 years; yet in a case surrounded with doubt and no physical evidence, a man is put to death.

Now, don’t get me wrong, the family of Officer Mark MacPhail is also suffering. It is a damn shame that a man who was coming to the rescue of another man being beat is killed—that too is a travesty and an atrocity. And, indirectly, the family still has no justice—relatively speaking. The killer is still walking the Earth.

In the end, is death the answer? Is the killing of another person the logical conclusion of justice? I ponder those questions, because the police officers who killed friends of mine, students of mine, and parents are still walking the Earth as well. Do I want death for them? I cannot say as of yet, so I too struggle with these issues. I do know that revenge killings are not the answer; yet they are woven into the social fabric and philosophy of this country.

As a Black man living in this country, I don’t fear getting blown up by some terrorist. I don’t fear some guy on a tape telling “me” that he wants to “kill me.” I don’t fear “terrorism” in its popular state. I don’t fear the overthrowing of our government by Muslim idealist. Let me tell you what I do fear. What happened to Troy Davis (and the countless amounts of other Black men in this country of ours) is what I fear…every day. As a Black man, you are always 1 foot away from the prison industrial complex; you are one breath away from being accused of something you didn’t do, but because someone “saw” you, you’re guilty. I fear the “justice” system in this country and that it will probably never produce “justice” for me in my lifetime. I fear that even a simple misdemeanor on my record will keep me from gainful employment; even with 4 degrees, 3 books, publications, and a list of stunning references. I fear being pulled over every single time; because I never know when it will be “my turn.”

I am Troy Davis. I know Troy Davis’ in the communities I work in. I’ve known Troy Davis in my classroom. I’ve seen Troy Davis in the store being looked at as a thug, simply because the messages that others have seen in the media about him are dominant in their minds.

This death is an atrocity. I cannot say it any other way. The execution taking place in a state with a history of racism and prejudicially biased decisions behooves the critical mind to ask what else is going on behind the scenes. Moreover, how does a Christian respond with Christ’s love in the face of such carnages? How does Thurman’s question reside with those who call themselves followers of Christ? What if we, in the Christ following community, actually took up a cause to truly engage the injustice of racism, sexism, and the prison industrial complex? Would it make you too “liberal” in the face of your friends? Or can we stand together on this issue regardless of social face?

I for one am ready to make this place a bit better for the little girl I call my daughter to live in. My prayer is for Troy Davis’ family. I pray for the family of Officer Mark MacPhail. I pray for our country as we are headed into a future unlike any other. I pray for the madness, hatred, and ignorance enveloped within racism that it would begin to be undone for some who are in positions of power, privilege, and with resources and that they would act…now.

Godspeed Troy Davis.

Comments

I made a quick study into the case, which led me to wonder how you could possibly present this the way you did. You make it sound like everyone who witnessed this Mr. Davis shoot the police officer is lying (there were 34 witnesses - 9 of which "recanted) while the people who recanted are telling the truth. You leave out the physical evidence that Mr. Davis was indisputably convicted of another crime with a gun whose shell casings match those found at the scene of the BK parking lot. You fail to mention that his case was reviewed by NUMEROUS people and all found him to be guilty based on the evidence. You are therefore calling ALL of these people racist murderers.

I don't ever want to see an innocent person get executed. You might think I'm a fool or worse for believing that the 25 other witnesses are telling the truth and that the jury who saw all the evidence made the right decision, but so be it.

I love your passion for justice and I sincerely hope that Mr. Davis has asked the Lord for forgiveness for his sins and is now enjoying eternity with Him. It is my opinion, though, that you are not seeing the whole picture in this case.

Respectfully,

Steve

Steve,

Thanks for commenting. However, I think it is you who are not seeing the whole picture. I've been following this case for about 5 years, so I'm not sure where you get your data from. But, it does prove that there was and still is much "reasonable doubt" around this case which is why the injustice was done in executing an innocent man. Second, it is strange to me, how you could ignore the history of racism and bigotry in this country toward African Americans; right there we have an ideological difference and one that I fear will keep White and Blacks divided. I wish things were "black and white" in court, but, from first hand experience, "justice" and "the law" depends on several things: money, status, color of your skin, and who you know. Moreover, there is also who the judge and prosecution is--those all determine cases. This case was never really looked at by anyone outside of Georgia and courts tend to favor the conditions I listed above in Southern states.

Therefore, yes, I am calling that system racist and unjust--even if there were persons of color in the mix; it doesn't matter, the system itself is corrupt.

But, once again, we're missing key elements to this conversation here: a history of deadly racism towards African Americans in this country. Without understanding that, engaging that, and thereby accepting it not only for me, but for yourself as well (This country was founded on a demonic racist hatred toward Blacks cloaked in Christianity which must be dealt with), we will continue to "miss each other" in this conversation.

I suggest seeing the documentary "The Color Of Fear" and begin unpacking that a bit. Then, get into W.E.B .Du Bois and Edward Blum's excellent book on Du Bois' religion. I also suggest taking a look at Cornel West's Race Matters.

And yes, Troy was a committed Christian in his jail cell and was in prayer those last few moments by all accounts from eye witnesses.

beats by dre Oh, Oh, long lines of the Sun, you can not back this way in our under water laxative, huh, huh. Major General finished smiled, handed the cup to the mouth, a mouthful of tea from the adversarial to. dr dre casque heartbeats WduoXWYn www.beatsbydrdrecasque.com Zhuo hand: this I cry so also. "So Zhong Guan are crying. To sit in one Fu Zhang laughed, saying:" lower-ranking or poor, to the night crying out, beats studio

I agree that there has been a deplorable history of injustice and violence against African Americans in this country - one that frankly makes me ashamed to be part of this country and part of the Christian faith - which as you say was (and still is) used to justify bigotry in hatred in people's hearts.
I have not been following the case for very long at all, but when I read the news I like to try and get both sides of the story and, if possible, come to a clearer picture of what is really happening. It seemed to me that the claims by Mr. Davis's supporters were SO outrageous - how could there be such a blatant and public display of injustice in today's America? There's got to be more to the story, I thought. And what I had read indicated that the 7 witnesses who recanted their testimony were not the only witnesses - that there were about 25 others that maintained their account. Details about a Batman shirt and a previous crime using the same gun that was used at the scene. All of what I read could be a complete fabrication, though - so I will defer to you as the expert.
So the real question to me is this: Why, if this is such a blatant case of injustice against an innocent man, are there not marches, sit-ins, protests, etc.? Why isn't Obama getting involved? Do people just not care?

Yes, I too ask a lot of those questions, but there were a lot of those marches, protests, petitions, and sit ins. It just didn't to any good. I don't know Obama so I can't speak for him, but I do know there were many asking the same thing.

I too try to seek both sides of every story. I try to look at things rationally. However, when it comes to the justice system and many ethnic minorities, it is simply unbalanced. So much so, that it seems as if people are just "making stuff up" because it is so overwhelming.

I know this has inspired many to take some more action. I for one am committed to this cause of justice for all.

»  Become a Fan or Friend of this Blogger
About
Daniel White Hodge, PhD, a Hip Hop scholar & cultural theorist focuses on race relations, film, cultural trends, and spirituality. His book, The Soul Of Hip Hop (IVP) deals with the theological gospel of Hip Hop culture & its people.


Media
Resources