EMAIL THIS PAGE       PRINT       RSS      

The Sex Appeal of Social Justice (And Why Jesus’ Love Turns More Heads)

(Here is a reposting from last year. It's still important.) 

I’ve come to an interesting conclusion. If helping your fellow man is like buying a car, you have two basic options: purchasing the sexy late model edition that makes heads turn, or going with the clunky used car that few notice and even fewer covet.

Without judging this trio’s motives, Barack, Brad, and Bono belong to the first category whether they want to or not. So do the high school kids who fatten up their fancy college apps with obligatory volunteerism and the pro athletes who, through “giving back,” score twice as many endorsement deals as the ones who don’t. You could also include entire political campaigns, blood drives that get you out of work early, and your sister-in-law who uses the Thanksgiving meal at the homeless shelter merely as a photo-op for her family scrapbook.

Pragmatists argue that we need all sorts of reasons for helping the weak among us, even the ones with nary a spiritual motive. Fred in the nursing home needs his bedpan changed, and it doesn’t matter whether his caregiver is a devoted grandson or a minimum wage worker who needs a paycheck, right? The desperate aren’t picky—they’ll take any hope they can get. I sort of get that line of reasoning. I mean, if a sixteen year old purchases an ultra-chic sweater that helps to fund micro-loans in Bangladesh—and she happens to look hot in the process—why does that matter? Isn’t the end result what counts?

But lately I’m worried about blurring the line between sounds-right, governmental “social justice” and the kind of work that people do simply because Jesus Christ changed their life. When there is no distinction, when there is little difference between corporate tax credits and the widow’s mite, then we have lost the powerful testimony of our Savior.

The humanists would prefer it this way. They believe that we live here for a while and create our own manmade hope before returning to eternal dust. In their minds, the religious folks are just doing nice stuff for people in order to earn favor from a fabled god. If there were something else besides the eighty-some odd years of a man’s life (or forty-some odd years for an Ethiopian) to make us care for one another, then at least let’s find out the difference.

I John 3: 16-18 exposes the unique cause and effect of divine—not merely human—transformation: We know what real love is because Jesus gave up his life for us. So we also ought to give up our lives for our brothers and sisters. And since he knows that few of us will ever need to give this level of sacrifice, John adds:  If someone has enough money to live well and sees a brother or sister in need but shows no compassion—how can God’s love be in that person? Dear children, let’s not merely say that we love each other; let us show the truth by our actions.

The second, less shiny, category of helping your fellow man includes all sorts of people whose names, if I dared list them, are unrecognizable. Their ministries are often small with great personal cost. The hope they peddle is of the brightest kind, but outsiders might not notice. The impact of Jesus Christ in their lives compels them to fix, teach, bandage, feed, and train, sometimes to groups of five or fewer, often in lonely places.

When Jesus attends to the wounded, he goes for the body and the soul. So when the paralytic finds himself awkwardly lowered from the rafters during one of Jesus’ teaching parties (thanks to his buddies who heard about free universal health care), he discovers that settling only for social justice would’ve been a lousy pick. Instead, Jesus goes right for the soul first and says, “Son, your sins are forgiven” before distributing a new pair of legs.  

I am not saying that my faith prevents me from supporting social programs, nor should followers of Jesus Christ discredit the work of so many decent causes. Melinda Gates’ philanthropic genius is still a wonder to behold, and the good people in the Peace Corps, say, are doing important, humane work. But Jesus’ love is not just another brand to buy in a big aisle of equally nice love-products. It provides a testimony of a changed life.

One homeless man in my town left the Fresno Rescue Mission because, in his words, “there’s too much God in this place.” He will no doubt go on to find another program passing out spare change in the name of social justice. I wish him well in his journey, for his body certainly needs sustenance. But I doubt he’ll find anyone who really loves him. I know social justice has all the sex appeal these days, but if you ask me, the God-changed heart is the real head turner.

Comments

I've been struggling with this same concept for a few months now! It's kind of easy for me to be cynical when I look a band or political candidate's endeavors to "help the world out." I can see how it could easily be a marketing ploy rather than authentic. However, I just picked up Bono's speech on AIDS to the President at that prayer breakfast a few years back in book form and it's pretty heartfelt and genuine. Anyway, you bring up a really interesting topic that I think is on a lot of people's minds right now so thanks for that.

That is an excellent article. Amen

excellent.

I totally agree with what you're saying and you're spot on. It's the reason I re-evaluate my commitments and service every year at church and it's the reason why I've served in several different arena's. Being a person of principle and someone my parents say have huge standards for people I'm not saying this lightly. But I think that there is so much that needs to be done and so many people who despite hearing about the horrible things going on in the world turn a blind eye and ear to it anyway, that screaming it from the rooftops and making it "cool" maybe the only way to shake people out of their apathy to do SOMETHING, ANYTHING about it. If that's what it takes to get the ball rolling and to start to making a dent in the social issues facing the world then I think God will bless even those who's ambitions are for personal gain and world acclamation.

And those of us who know better can still silently serve and go about our business and be disgusted that it was maybe not done with the right heart, but at least it was done.....

As usual, I'm blown away by your writing, Caroline. You can have me laugh and flinch in one paragraph. Amazing.

And I love the topic. Maybe I feel defensive for my non-Christian friends who are committed to helping others. The problem is that I have known atheists who have floored me by their love and compassion. I have been convicted by atheists.

When you write, "I wish him well in his journey, for his body certainly needs sustenance. But I doubt he’ll find anyone who really loves him," I wonder. Does the church really own the market on love? I have friends since high school, who as far as I know has never known Christ, but has loved me through thick and thin, when others have shown me judgement. What do we do with that?

So, I guess I agree that Jesus love is the best love. It's amazing, transformative, everlasting, all of it. But it's not the only love and it's not the one kind of effective love. By God's grace, there is quite a bit of love that out there that's beyond the Church's control.

You bring up some great points about this, Mark. I recently wondered some of the same things when I wrote about weddings and marriage recently (Is God a part of ALL love, even those not directly inspired by his salvation?) And I know what you mean about wanting to defend the beautiful, charitable acts of unbelievers.

I'm inclined to think, though, that none of us would be able to truly love without the love of God working along the edges. I know people can explain it via pragmatism or science or survival or temperament or whatever, but Jesus' love seems to transcend all that in some unexplainable ways.

Keep pushing me to think and get better. That's what this is for.

Mark, you bring up a huge question. Very important. I understand your question, "Does the church really own the market on love?" The church may not own the market on love, but God is love.

A link from Brett Kunkle's blog, http://www.conversantlife.com/theology/the-problem-of-evil-everyones-pro... includes a reference to The Abusurdity of Life without God. To summarize, the atheist has a dilemma. If there is no God, life has no meaning. If the atheist then continues to live as though life has meaning (sharing love), this is inconsistent.

I quote, "It is inconsistent to say life is objectively absurd and then to say one may create meaning for his life. If life is really absurd, then man is trapped in the lower story. To try to create meaning in life represents a leap to the upper story."

This is one of the points that brought me back to my faith. God is love, whether atheists want to acknowledge it or not. They don't recognize their creator who gave them the capacity to love.

The so-called "good deeds" of those who do them with selfish motives are filthy rags. They will be exposed as merely wood, hay, or stubble. Not that we all have not benefited from them or offered them at some time, it's just that in light of eternity, it's the motives of the heart that will count in heaven. Good reminder.

Caroline: This is a well written and thoughtful reflection which reminds me to be aware of the trap of "good deeds." I believe that as Jesus' love fills your heart, it cannot stay contained, and you will naturally want to and will seek out opportunities to share.

»  Become a Fan or Friend of this Blogger
About
Why Cracks? Because in my suburban world, the collision of faith and modern life is sometimes messy. Can I find beauty, not only in Christianity’s smooth concrete, but also in the broken places?


Media
Resources