EMAIL THIS PAGE       PRINT       RSS      

The Curious Case of Racial Discourse

President Obama has his hands full. On one end, if he presses too hard for equality and justice, he will be crucified for “playing the race card.” On the other side of it, if he sits still and says very little, at the end of his presidency not only will Blacks remonstrate but many other ethnic minorities will bawl for justice and equality against the beast of racism. In the recent weeks, we have seen the struggle President Obama has had; Shirley Sherrod is case in point. Moreover, now you have Charlie Rangel and Maxine Waters being probed by the ethics committee; both are African American. Does race play a role in all this? Of course.

This country has never dealt with its deep embedded history of racism. From the U.S.’s inception (and beyond for that matter) racism has been at the forefront of politics, the economy, and “expansion” (e.g. Manifest Destiny). During the 1960’s we had a small window of opportunity to engage and embrace these issues; the time was ripe and open for the conversation. However, after the Civil Rights Act was signed into law, many people felt as though racism was a “dead thing.” The problem then gets placed under the carpet to seethe, simmer, and eventually boil over leaving ethnic minorities to blame when they call out for justice. Hence, it stands to reason why we have these eruptions in the news of racially charged cases, politics, and narrative.

The President is caught between doing what he knows is the right thing in terms of leading out on the issues of racial inequality, and getting re-elected. This was evident in the swift firing of Sherrod over some drummed up charges made by a fanatic who plays on emotion and people’s fears. The Obama administration reacted, partly, out of self-preservation; no one wanted to be blamed for harboring a “racist.” Republicans would have eaten that up; just in time for elections. Moreover, if Obama pushes too hard on race he does run the serious risk of being assassinated. Keep in mind he already has the security level of a president being threatened constantly. Moreover, the patterns for ethnic minorities, in particular, who speak out against racism get publically shunned and as NY Times writer Matt Bai puts it have “public outrage and humiliation” to contend with—consequently one of the major problems.

Once again, Obama is caught in the middle…what do you do? This goes deeper than what we actually see on the surface though. The country is still shocked that a negro is even in office. Many in the South, who still feel sensitive over that Civil War thing, look at Washington in complete contempt. Why? Well, there are a list of reasons. For example, no matter how educated, smart, sharp, wise, or polished a Black man is, they are still looked at as less than, incompetent, and or placed in positions of power because of some type of Affirmative Action or quota needing to be met. That is a stereotype long-lived and extremely difficult to overcome, if even able to be overcome.

In my classes, I have students take a social photograph of their school. I ask them to see who is in power, who has decision-making power, and who is in charge. I ask them to notice blue-collar jobs around school and who performs the grunt work. I then ask that they observe the gender and race of each of those positions. Overwhelmingly, White and male is in the power seat while ethnic minorities are in positions of service with the least power. But what is even more imperative to note is that most White students do not seem to care; in fact, most say that “God put them there” and why would we hire a minority over a “qualified” White person—the sub text being that the minority is not even qualified to begin with and that Whiteness must be some divine and pious appointment.

No matter how many books I publish, degrees I get, intellectual words I use, suites I wear, or shined up grins I give, when I walk into that all White classrooms, I am still battling those historical stereotypes and images placed upon me by years of media and social conditioning of Blacks. Thus, it is even more an issue for someone in such a public office such as the presidency.

For White’s who are new to this issue or even tired of this issue, it is very difficult to have these types of conversations. Many White’s have rarely had to comprehend White racial identity and or be placed in constant situations where they haven’t had the choice of being the minority. Therefore, since White’s still control most of the power in this country, it complicates the issue even further. Someone like me is looked at as a complainer, someone who is playing the victim, playing the race card, not being able to pull my self up by my bootstraps, or, even worse, not having enough faith. The conversation is even muddier when I speak with a White person who sincerely believes that I bring these problems on myself by talking about them and or entertaining the idea that racism still exists.

The President has a hard road ahead. Maxine and Charlie are two long standing players in Washington and if Obama were to call out the obvious for what is happening to them, he too would be called a racist and lose those precious votes come next election—a problem in and of itself.

So, where do we go with this? What do we do with the curious case of race and racism? Do we all just “take it to Jesus?” I wish it were that simple, because even there—in theological discourse—we see the power of racism as well. Non-contextualized Gospel messages, one size fits all salvation approaches, one style worship only being accepted, Westernized styles of devotions, disenfranchising “other” labels, the dampening of variety in approaching God, and even interpretations of sacred scripture have all been shot through racialized lenses. In fact, when Rome concentrated power of the church, they castigated any other form of worship and theology; it was their way or nothing. In effect, anyone who didn’t practice church the way they laid it out was condemned and excommunicated. We have some problems.

It is important to begin dealing with some of these issues. Recent tragedies such as Oscar Grant, remind us that we are nowhere near what we have come to idealize as a “great country.” We’ve cuddled the mythology of “justice for all” far too long without ever looking at what that really means for “all.” We’ve also ignored those voices on the margins who cry for equality and justice but are looked at as trouble makers, loud mouths, and unpatriotic. Moreover, we have looked upon God as a God who only really “loves” one type of people; multi-culturalism takes work—a lot of it. And we cannot falter just because it seems or appears that things have “gotten better” because for many they have not. We have a presidency with the capability of taking us into a new era of racial equality, but are impotent of doing so and caught in the cross hairs of special interest and votes.

Dear God, help us.

Comments

Dan,

Interesting piece. Too much to get into here. Have you watched that C-SPAN "The State of Black America" hosted by Tavis Smiley that I sent you? Many of the issues you raise in this piece are discussed in the midst of that round table discussion.

I agree the President is in a difficult position, but I also think that African Americans are looking at Mr. Obama as some sort of messianic figure and that gaze is misappropriated.

As Eric Michael Dyson said, he is not Moses - he's PHARAOH. Not him literally but the office he holds. He is not Dr. King but in fact the beneficiary of his blood that was spilled in the ground of Selma Birmingham, and Montgomery but to name a few so that , he could have the opportunities he had as a young black man in America and that he now enjoys as President of the United States. People of color need to stop making these gross and erroneous comparisons.

By the very nature of the office and the constructs of power that surround it, he can never be the bridge between troubled waters. If that was his true desire, to be that, then he would have been best served by not taking office and attempting to do those things furtherest away from the constructs of power.

We live in confusing and dark times my as you noted my friend. Times, where as the prophet Isaiah said "Those who call evil good and good evil." We live in such paradoxical times that the very constructs of injustice, the very facilitators of it now call the victims of injustice and racial prejudice - "racist"? As an ironic banner that marks represents 21st century America, it is now white America that calls out racial oppression and injustice for those that cry out to the very power that suppresses them. That too within itself is another irony of the times that we live in.

The most troublesome sign to me is, where are the prophet bearing witnesses that seemingly have always been there in times such as these that bear truth to the conscience of America? Where are those new voices that God calls up to speak to the conscience of a nation? Have we become so apathetic to our cause that we now look to our very oppressors to loosen the chains of bondage? Or is that we have fallen sway as the rest of America to the sins of hedonism, idolatry, greed and lust or to the isms of nationalism, spiritualism, capitalism, and legalism?

Where are those voices? More importantly where is God's people? It is times such as these that he has called us to. For a city on a hill cannot be hidden, and if we lose our saltiness then what is it worth but to be thrown on the ground and trampled underfoot by men.

Cornel West address this point succinctly :

"I speak as a Christian, one whose commitment to democracy is very deep but whose Christian convictions are deeper. Democracy is not my faith and American democracy is not my idol. To see the Gospel of Jesus Christ bastardized by imperial Christians and pulverized by Constantinian believers and then exploited by nihilistic elites of the American empire makes my blood boil. To be a Christian- a follower of Jesus Christ- is to love wisdom, love justice, and love freedom. If Christians do not exemplify this love and freedom, then we side with the nihilists of the empire that nailed him to the cross. To be a Christian is to live dangerously, honestly, freely, to step in the name of love as if you may land on nothing, yet to keep stepping because the something that sustains you no empire can give you and no empire can take away. This is the kind of vision and courage required to enable the renewal of a prophetic , democratic Christian identity in the age of the American empire." ©

I lift up my eyes to the hills.
From where does my help come?
My help comes from the Lord,
who made heaven and earth! Psalm 121

Joseph,
As usual wise words! I agree, Obama is not the Messianic figure, many Blacks have seen him as that...which speaks to the years of political, social, economic, and religious oppression which has tarnished this country for a long time...so it's two fold: 1) yes, be excited that a "black man" is in the White house; a house that slaves built, but 2) garnish that with the fact he is not a savior...tough cookies.

My whole point here is that race is such a "delicate" topic and tends to be overlooked in the case of the context. What I mean is, it's easy to see Mrs. Waters as "unethical" when in reality, she is doing nothing that her White predecessors haven't done for decades; but, since the political waters are so hot, she gets left standing when the music stops and yes, race becomes an issue once again--it's no surprise to me that so many Blacks are being called to "ethics" when a "black man" is in the White House.

Good words my man! We gotta get you to write that book!

Daniel, just want to say an excellent post (and what a photo!!!). I'm deeply grateful that you are writing for Conversant Life. We need your voice.

Thanks Mark. Appreciate that!

There's so much happening in our society today related to race it's just amazing at times...but its good to have a voice here!

»  Become a Fan or Friend of this Blogger
About
Daniel White Hodge, PhD, a Hip Hop scholar & cultural theorist focuses on race relations, film, cultural trends, and spirituality. His book, The Soul Of Hip Hop (IVP) deals with the theological gospel of Hip Hop culture & its people.


Media
Resources