In 2005, sociologist Christian Smith released a monumental
study of the spiritual lives of American youth. The study—called “The National
Study of Youth and Religion”—is detailed in the book Soul Searching and is an insightful and eye-opening account of what
students ages 13-17 believe about God and religion. A few months ago, Smith
released a follow-up book called Souls In Transition: The Religious
and Spiritual Lives of Emerging Adults
(Oxford, 2010) that follows these same students as they transition into
adulthood.
Like Soul Searching,
this book is a must-read for anyone—parents, youth pastors, and
teachers—interested in understanding the mindset of this generation. Smith is a
careful, thoughtful, and highly respected sociologist from Notre Dame. He
writes Souls in Transition to
inform about this generation rather than to persuade to a particular form of
ministry. Thus, people from various theological backgrounds will appreciate his
work.
For sake of clarity, the phrase “emerging adults” has
nothing to do with the Emergent Church. Rather, Smith uses it to refer to young
adults ages 18-23. According to Smith, “this book intends to provide the most
comprehensive and reliable understanding and explanation of the lives of
emerging adults in the United States today, particularly their religious and
spiritual lives” (p. 9). Smith is careful to emphasize that 24-29 year olds may
look very different than age group he has chosen to focus on.
The purpose of this blog post is to highlight some important
trends among emerging adults that Smith reveals in his study. I will shortly
follow up with Part 2 to offer some humble thoughts as to how this information
may shape ministry to this generation. Below are some quotes by Smith I found
particularly insightful about the spiritual lives of emerging adults from Souls
in Transition.
- Overwhelmed: “Most emerging
adults are close to being overwhelmed with all of the skills, tasks,
responsibilities, systems, and procedures they are having to learn”
(35).
- Optimistic: “In short, “In
short, cynical, weary, jaded, despondent, defeated, and the like are words that describe very few
emerging adults in America” (37).
-
No regrets: “Most of the
emerging adults who were interviewed explicitly denied feeling any regrets
about any of their past decisions…They clearly do not want to see themselves as
having regrets” (41).
-
Skeptics and perspectivalists: “Most
have great difficulty grasping the idea that a reality that is objective to
their own awareness or construction of it may exist that could have a significant
bearing on their lives. In philosophical terms, most emerging adults
functionally are soft ontological antirealists and epistemological skeptics and
perspectivalists…” (45)
-
Don’t hurt others: “One of the
core principles emerging adults seem to presuppose in thinking about moral
behavior is the imperative not to hurt others” (47).
-
Everybody’s different: “Nearly
any question asked of them about any norm, experience, rule of thumb,
expectation, or belief in life is very likely to get an answer beginning with
the phrase, ‘Well, everybody’s different, but for me…’” (48).
-
Individualism: “The absolute
authority for every person’s beliefs or actions is his or her own sovereign
self” (49).
-
Settling down is for later: “But
they also want to relish it [young adulthood] as the time to be young, have
fun, and avoid major responsibilities…Later, when they settle down they’ll be
sober, faithful, and responsible adults. The assumption seems to be, ‘Whatever
happens in my early twenties stays in my early twenties’” (57).
-
Relationships are amorphous: “Old
clear-cut labels, like ‘just friends,’ dating, courting, and engaged, for
instance, are too black-and-white for the way many emerging adults relate today…”
(58).
-
Cohabit to avoid divorce: “The
vast majority of emerging adults nonetheless believe that cohabiting is a smart
if not absolutely necessary experience and phase for moving toward an eventual
successful and happy marriage” (62).
-
Consumerism is fine: “The idea
of having any questions or doubts about the cycle of shopping, buying,
consuming, accumulating, discarding, and shopping appeared to be unthinkable to
them” (67).
-
Volunteering and giving are not
important: “The emerging adults studied in the interviews are not big on
volunteering and voluntary financial giving, at least at this point in their
lives” (71).
-
Focus on interpersonal
relationships: “Most of them are withdrawn from the public square and instead
submerged in interpersonal relationships in their private worlds. Few emerging
adults are involved in community organizations or other social change-oriented
groups or movements” (73).
-
Universalists: “57 percent
believe that many religions may be true” (134)
-
Partying, hooking up and sex are
common: “Most of them want to party, to hook up, to have sex in relationships,
and to cohabit; or if they do not do these things now, many at least want to
keep them as options for the future” (83).
Some of these findings may surprise you while others may
seem obvious to those who already work with this generation. Given this
information, how do we minister to this generation? Hang on, because that is a
topic we will explore in part 2.
Comments
This book looks really good. It is sad to see that the people today think this way. I'll check out the book but the excerpts you put here were enlightening. Tom @ youth group activities