EMAIL THIS PAGE       PRINT       RSS      

A Review of "Free Will" by Sam Harris

Last year I took a group of high school students to UC Berkeley to interact with skeptics. After spending an evening with S.A.N.E (Students for a Non-religious Ethos), I found myself in a conversation with an undergraduate student about the existence of free will. She told me that she recently embraced determinism and rejected free will.

 

In response to my query about why she changed her mind, she appealed to genetics, background forces, and environmental factors. In other words, she believed there is no free will because external forces determine beliefs. What she didn’t realize was that the justification she offered for her belief in determinism undermined her deterministic beliefs. She believed that she had evaluated the evidence and embraced the position—determinism—that is most logical. And yet if determinism were true she would have been incapable of evaluating evidence and freely following the logic because all her choices were already set. Logically speaking, her position was self-refuting. In other words, she sawed off the branch she was sitting on.

 

Sam Harris makes the exact same mistake in his recent book Free Will (Free Press, 2012). He denies the existence of free will, but like this girl, his arguments undermine this very position. Before offering my critique, let me briefly clarify his views.

 

After rightly emphasizing the importance of the question of free will, Harris concludes, “Free will is an illusion” (p. 5). According to Harris, we are not the conscious source of our actions and we could not have behaved differently in the past than we did. He says, “I, as the conscious witness of my experience, no more initiate events in my prefrontal cortex than I cause my heart to beat” (9). “In physical terms,” says Harris, “we know that every human action can be reduced to a series of impersonal events” (27).

 

Harris rightly points out that there are three main approaches to the problem of free will and determinism: determinism, libertarianism, and compatibilism. He then says, “Today, the only philosophically respectable way to endorse free will is to be a compatibilist” (16). But if determinism were true, as Harris asserts, why would any position be philosophically unrespectable? After all, people are determined to hold their beliefs—whether compatibilist, libertarian, or determinist—by forces outside of their control. Why would he bother to critique other positions if the people who hold them couldn’t have believed differently? In fact, his critique is just the result of chemicals moving in his brain, so why do they matter? What makes his chemicals more respectable than others?

 

Later in the book Harris says that giving up free will (and becoming more aware of the background causes of our feelings) allows people to have greater creative control over their lives. “Getting behind our conscious thoughts and feelings,” says Harris, “can allow us to steer a more intelligent course through our lives” (p. 47). Do you see the contradiction? The idea of “steering” a more intelligent course through life, of course, has no meaning in a deterministic world. On Harris’ view we can’t steer anything! The belief that we can steer our lives is an illusion. All of our beliefs and behavior are entirely the result of forces outside our control. In one breath Harris says all our beliefs are determined, but then in another breath he speaks about steering the course of our lives. Which is it?

 

Here are some other brief comments in Free Will that puzzle me.

 

Harris critiques the idea of an immortal soul as one of the cruelest concepts in history (p. 56). Yet if his deterministic views are correct then people who embrace the soul were determined to do so and could not have believed differently. Why bother to critique then? He might as well critique water for boiling at 100˚ C.

 

He says that dispensing with the idea of free will allows us to focus on things that matter most—assessing risk, protecting the innocent, and deterring crime (p. 53). He seems to be implying that we ought to accept his deterministic views for the betterment of mankind. Yet again, if determinism is true then we can’t change any of our beliefs—we can’t freely follow his logic since our beliefs are already set. The very fact that he argues for his position undermines his stated belief in determinism.

 

Harris offers a mild critique of conservatives who seem to have no compassion for orphans or those born with clubbed feet (p. 62). But if his deterministic views are correct they couldn’t help it. Conservatives are forced to believe this because of their parents, genes, and environment (as are liberals). Again, why is he bothering to critique them?

 

There are many more inconsistencies throughout Free Will, but the point should be well stated—Harris argues against free will, yet all of his arguments rest upon the existence of free will.

 

Harris raises important issues related to the free will debate, and I would recommend it to anyone who wants a naturalistic view of human behavior. But the problem is that he doesn’t take his views far enough. For example, in the conclusion he says, “The illusion of free will is itself an illusion” (p. 64). He’s right. If determinism is true, then the belief in free will is an illusion. But why stop at the belief in free will? It would seem to follow logically that all our beliefs are illusions if determinism is true. In fact, the belief that “the illusion of free will is itself an illusion” is itself an illusion…and so is the rest of the entire book.

Comments

Harris is correct. It is pointless to keep fighting, you must be able to see it by now. Truth, freedom, peace, love, are all illusions, a temporary construct of a feeble human intellect trying desperately to justify an existence that is without meaning or purpose!

Teenage metabolism slows down significantly when they spend time to linger in front of the television. In fact, your metabolism will be faster when you rest rather than watching television. With an average teenager spends 30 hours a week watching television, it is a lot of time to make a slow metabolism, which means making greater risk of obesity. So, if you do not have the energy to get out and exercise, weight loss Tips cepat hamil take a nap or just sit and think instead of watching TV can help you lose weight. MayoClinic recommends consuming less than 75 calorie sweet foods, 3-5 servings of fats, 3-7 servings of protein and dairy, 4-8 servings of carbohydrates, at least 3 servings of fruit and at least 4 servings of vegetables every day. Avoid fast food and find new and exciting ways to cook food that is more satisfying to avoid overeating.

This is exactly what I was looking for. Thanks for sharing this great article! iklan google adwords

I agree with you

Great post.Thank you for taking the time to posting this information very helpfull!. I discovered so many interesting things inside your blog especially. - alat kesehatan

Hi, just wanted to let you know that I appreciate your post. I hope there will be more good posts here! - isi ulang pemadam api

I do wish there were more people like you around on the interwebs. Not many people are careful with their words, including myself sometimes. I have written things I would love to take back, goo work, keep it up - selimut murah

i did enjoy reading articles posted on this site. They are very useful and informative. Many thanks to all the author who are so kind to share their wonderful ideas. serum korea | Kaminomoto | pembesar payudara kitchen set murah | obat gemuk | magic plus white cream | cream walet | penghilang bekas luka | sabun susu beras | pemutih wajah
perawatan rambut | minyak bulus | produk kecantikan

you're ready to alleviate cash from your debit mastercard or even spot a burden with settlement debit mastercard at identical time. you're ready to alleviate cash the maximum amount as almost about any add on your own debit mastercard along with your personalised DETECTION amount dependent deal. you'll be able to even utilize your current debit mastercard or even mastercard to hide services. Any ease value is typically used
Cipto Junaedy
Cipto Junaedy
unit link terbaik di indonesia commonwealth life investra link
Cipto Junaedy
UBCPoker.com Situs Judi Poker Online Terbaik Terpercaya

Nama saya Cipto Junaedy, Saya mengucapkan banyak terima kasih atas artikel anda yang bermanfaat ini, semoga di lain kesempatan saya bisa comment di situs ini. Saya juga punya informasi yang tak kalah menarik seputar RAJAPOKER88.COM AGEN TEXAS POKER DOMINO ONLINE INDONESIA TERPERCAYA, IDRPoker.COM Agen Texas Poker dan Domino Online Indonesia Terpercaya dan masih ada banyak lagi review saya mengenai situs poker online yang sayang sekali jika anda lewarkan di antaranya yang paling menarik yaitu POKERSTAR88.com Agen Texas Poker Dan Domino Online Indonesia Terpercaya | DaunPKR.com Agen Poker Domino Online Indonesia Terbaik Terbesar Dan Terpercaya | PokerPelangi.com Agen Texas Poker Domino Online Indonesia Terpercaya dan tak lupa pula kunjungi halaman ini untuk anda yang suka taruhan online Agen Bola, Taruhan Bola, SBOBET

Your good knowledge and kindness in playing with all the pieces was very useful. I don’t know what I would have done if I had not encountered such a step like this. baju gamis

Simply wish to say your article is as astonishing. The clarity in your post is simply great and i could assume you are an expert on this subject. Well with your permission let me to grab your RSS feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please keep up the gratifying work. emergency glass repair cairns

Harris offers a mild critique of conservatives who seem to have no compassion for orphans or those born with clubbed feet (p. 62). But if his deterministic views are correct they couldn’t help it. Conservatives are forced to believe this because of their parents, genes, and environment (as are liberals). Again, why is he bothering to critique them?

Top Ten Web Hosting

I just loved shopping there for all kinds of great books. I miss the Bodhi Tree just like all of it's fans. Hoping for a return one day of the might Bodhi Tree. Please come back and share your amazing books with us again. I've had issues with hackers and I'm looking at alternatives for another platform. I would be fantastic
if you could point me in the direction of a good platform obat tradisional penurun asam urat thank you

Your blog has some of the most fascinating information! I've read several pages here and I just had to comment and let you know that I thought you've been doing a great job here. Keep it up!
jimmy hantu untuk ikan lele dan obat asam urat dan obat rematik murah jakarta

I really enjoy simply reading all of your weblogs for My Game. Simply wanted to inform you that you have people like me who appreciate your work for Modifikasi Motor Vixion. Definitely a great post. Hats off to you! The information that you have provided is very helpful on Tempat Wisata.

I also enjoy it. Best custom essay writing services also like this website. Now, Took me age to foretell sum the commentarys, inactive I indeed enjoyed the item. It proved to be Quite cooperative to me moreover I am unfailing to total the commenter here! It's always stunning whereas you can nay singular be aware, only further entertained!

Thanks for sharing amazing article. i am very glad to your work for Desain Rumah Minimalis Sederhana . you give me nice and helpful information keep it up. keep it good posting. i wait your next post. visit i provide Panduan dan cara and give other signs solution Modifikasi Motor Satria FU services.

Free Will" brings together the essential readings in the debate about free will and determinism." "Written by top scholars in the field, the essays represent some of the clearest and most accessible thinking on this subject. The introduction offers a concise yet thorough mapping of this age-old debate as well as a helpful overview of the selections.

To what extent are we truly free? Are our actions determined? If so, are we morally responsible for our actions? And does such determinism necessarily conflict with free will? This volume covers wide-ranging issues in the debate about free will, including the distinction between freedom of choice and freedom of will, moral responsibility, determinism, and compatibility.

This compact collection of some of the best and most provocative writing on free will is ideal for anyone who wants to explore this complex problem.

binäre optionen

yeah you're right, I think thanks for this Harga Motor Honda

Hey, that quote is from the Matrix Revolution. Mr. Anderson says it to Neo right before Neo says he fights for freedom. I always wondered why Mr. Anderson would fight against Neo by trying to convince him that he ought not fight. Hmmmm.....

Hi Sean

Would you be able to share your comments about this article by Kennels Daniels: http://www.kwdaniels.com/1/post/2012/03/is-free-will-an-illusion.html

He seems to suggest that our wants (which are caused by a chain of other causes) ultimately determine our choices. For instance, his (seemingly voluntary) lifting of the pink finger in response to determinism could itself be caused by his "reflexive impulse against the repugnant notion that all his actions were outside of his control".

Please comment.
Andrew

Your web site include worth it to read document.I really like a person"s document, appreciation for revealing. software akuntansi

Wow, what a blog! I mean, you just have so much guts to go ahead and tell it like it is. You're what blogging needs, an open minded superhero who isn't afraid to tell it like it is. This is definitely something people need to be up on. Good luck in the future, man. Remy Wigs

Thanks for sharing amazing article. i am very glad to your work for Jual Perlengkapan Bayi . you give me nice and helpful information keep it up. keep it good posting. i wait your next post. visit i provide resep kue kering and give other signs solution samsung galaxy s3 services.

Sean, you said, "Yet again, if determinism is true then we can’t change any of our beliefs—we can’t freely follow his logic since our beliefs are already set." Why do we need to freely follow his logic before our beliefs can be rational? What if our beliefs are determined by Harris' logic? You say that "The very fact that he argues for his position undermines his stated belief in determinism," but I don't see how. Maybe Harris argues for determinism BECAUSE he's a determinist. He thinks that his arguments will play some part in the causal chain, resulting in other people adopting his belief. And he's determined to make his arguments by his desire to persuade other people. So you could have a deterministic causal chain that goes something like this:

Chemical reactions in Harris' brain cause him to want to persuade other people to adopt determinism.

Harris' desire to persuade other people of determinism causes him to make arguments for determinism.

Harris' arguments for determinism interact with the rest of the world causing some people to adopt determinism and failing to cause others to adopt determinism.

Why is free will necessary? Do you think our beliefs are under the control of the will such that we can simply choose to believe? It seems to me that THAT would undermine our rationality since then there is no necessary connection between reasons and beliefs. Beliefs would arise spontaneously and acausally. It seems to me that the more hand "reasons" play in forming our beliefs, the more rational we are. Since reasons have the MOST hand in forming our beliefs when our beliefs are completely determined by reasons, we are the most rational when our beliefs are determined by reasons, and not when they are chosen for no reason at all.

Good work! Your post is an excellent example of why I keep coming back to read your excellent quality content. Herosoftmedia

Full of intellectual beauty shape allows the OL in winter still dominate the office, popular full dress makes you still full of strong woman,Moncler Outlet very slim dress with Lady taste collarless jacket open chest width, classic coat can be out of fashion

I have found very useful information over there, thanks for sharing this. http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-wales-politics-23249384

Harris's basic message is that the time has come to freely question the idea of religious faith.-Missed Fortune

I always find such amazing posts on this website and today's post was really amazing. Thanks dude jual oleh-oleh haji

Maybe you are wrong about it. Actually, Ruckus Marketing also have replies for it but Now, actually, I obsession this tell additionally enough truly. I personally endure this guide scrupulous about everyday. It's my adventure to my coffee, can't commence beginnings minus it! It's exceptionally fascinating foster spectacular, additional particularly nearby for me. This is an incredible likewise terrific blog. Thank you exceptionally plenty.

It will take me half a day to digest everything you said here, I wish I was there myself to participate to this conversation. I thought I new some answers but now you showed me that everything can be twisted again and again, I need to think deeper and find something that can't be twisted. It's actually the theme of the week for me since I recently found a articles critique help resource that showed me few techniques I wasn't aware of in exposing in writing an idea of this kind.

This is my first visit in this website. I really impressed to read this website. Thanks for writtnig this fabulous blog posting.Nice efforts you make, keep up this kind of fair work forever. here

Awesome blog. I enjoyed reading your articles. Keep post dude :D jual crocs terbaru

You are right in this case. Few essay shark also have these types of things and I like this. Your such a fortunate undivided to retain this donation container of understanding that's why I agree with you.

This is really satisfied by the great info is visible in this blog that to very much information in this blog. Thanks a lot for providing the great info is visible in this blog and using the great technology in this blog.
buy research papers

You Are Right about this post. I have read about this from custom thesis writing service and Now, I shall share this to my friends. This is a really good read for me, Must admit that you are one of the best bloggers I ever saw.Thanks for posting this informative article.

Well said ! i must say that it is very informative article. This is another really very amazing and interesting post. You have provided the post that is directly related to our interest. Thank you
steel frames

Very interesting blog. Lot of blogs I see these days don't really provide anything that I'm interested in, but I'm most definitely interested in this one. Just thought that I would post and let you know..
health products

I wanted to thank you for this great read I definitely enjoying every little bit of it and I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
Wasseradern

You got a actually advantageous website, I collect been here noble for about an hour. I am a novice across your bash is really fullness an stimulus for me. Hyperthyroidism Symptoms also like this website.

This is like my fourth time stopping over your Blog. Normally, I do not make comments on website, but I have to mention that this post really pushed me to do so. Really great post. payment processing.

Wonderful post!This is very useful to many readers like me.Being a student, I am requiring myself to read "" articles more often and your writing just caught my interest.Thank you ! Wow! Thank you! I continually needed to write on my site something like that. www.aftec.com.

yeah, Right about it. I heard this from best essay writing services. The information and the aspect were just wonderful. I think that your viewpoint is deep, it’s just well thought out and truly incredible to see someone who knows how to put these thoughts so well. Good job!

Wonderful post!This is very useful to many readers like me.Being a student, I am requiring myself to read "" articles more often and your writing just caught my interest.Thank you ! Wow! Thank you! I continually needed to write on my site something like that. www.aftec.com.

This is my first time i visit here. I found so many entertaining stuff in your blog, especially its discussion. From the tons of comments on your articles, I guess I am not the only one having all the leisure here! Keep up the good work.
bestessay.com

I stumbled across your blog and was instantly amazed with all the useful information that is on it. Great post, just what i was looking for and i am looking forward to reading your other posts soon.

total merchant services

Why didn't I think about this? I hear exactly what you're saying and I'm so happy that I came across your blog. You really know what you're talking about, and you made me feel like I should learn more about this.Ontra Website SEO

»  Become a Fan or Friend of this Blogger
About
Sean McDowell is a teacher, author, speaker, husband and father. He is an avid fan of college basketball, ping-pong, and his favorite superhero is the Amazing Spiderman.