Now, am I some pessimistic, narcissist who hates the Holiday season? No. Of course not. But our society has turned the Christmas season into quite the buying frenzy followed with the guilt-ridden mantra of having to lose all that weight and get out of debt in the New Year, which most fail after the first 30 days anyways. I love the Christmas season. It gives my family and I time to reflect, connect, and prepare for the New Year ahead. It is also a time to see friends and get that “cozy” feeling that we have all come to love around this time of year. No, no, I love this season. But, I’m troubled when I see fights, people getting trampled, cars getting scratched, and even people getting shot over the tickle me Elmo doll—or whatever “must have gift” craze is dominating the buying frenzy that year. This year we didn’t really do gifts. My wife and I bought a tree, decorated it, and Mahalia was happy with the boxes and fuzz that came in the boxes. Before you go and feel sorry for us or judge us for not celebrating Christmas “the right way” with our little one, let me tell you: this year we were really forced to “trim down” our spending—like so many other Americans in this economic recession. Money has not been our friend this year and work is even harder to come by—thus, no gifts. However, what it forced us to do was to refocus back on the real “reason for the season”: Christ, family, friends, good times, and memories that will last a lifetime. And guess what, it was really good! Not having money was a real worldview shifter and gave us some perspective on where our priorities really lie. It also helped us to enjoy each other as people and to reflect on what Christ has done in our lives over the last year. This doesn’t mean I’m hating on anyone who went out and got that 60 inch plasma with the Bose sound system—no, no. Go on with ya bad self. Hell, I can’t lie and say I don’t want that at some level. But in the end, we came to realize just what the culture industry of Christmas has done to our own perception and social understanding of this Holiday season. The great social critic and philosopher Theodor Adorno defined a culture industry that, “…involves the production of works for the reproduction and mass consumption, thereby organizing ‘free’ time, the remnant domain of freedom under capital in accordance with the same principles of exchange and equivalence that reign in the sphere of production outside leisure, presents culture as the realization of the right of all to the gratification of desire while in reality continuing the negative integration of society” (The Culture Industry [1991: Blackwell Publishing] p.4). Adorno was concerned with looking at how hyper-consumption actually degraded us and turned us into blind consumers with a focused groupthink only to buy and consume for sole gratification. Adorno had it right in many ways, he asserted that “under capitalism all production is for the market; goods are produced not in order to meet human needs and desires, but for the sake of profit, for the sake of acquiring further capital” (The Culture Industry pp.5-6). We have, in essence, a capitalistic market that operates, as Naomi Klein has reminded us (Anti Globalist and author of No Logo), as a crack addict, seeking its next hit and feeding. No other “season” demonstrates this better than the Christmas season here in the States. Moreover, with more U.S. citizens going into debt and living beyond their means, what does this mean for our future? Does this make us venerable to a different type of “terrorist” attack? The culture industry of Christmas gets to me. It really didn’t hit me until my economic back was pressed against the wall this year. Our little girl was fine this Christmas year; she never knew the difference; she had one of the best Christmas’ ever with grandma in town. My wife had a great time as her and I had a chance to catch up on the year, our life, our marriage, and where we go in the New Year. It was great because I didn’t have to fight crowds, look for the “best parking spot” at the mall, and I spent time with the family and with good friends. Can this keep up every year though? What will happen once we do get some capital and income? I don’t know. But I do know that I want to continue this trend and focus less on the pure consumption of material just for the sake of consumption. Because as Adorno posits, “The mass culture…absorbs the truth content and expends itself in the material but all it has left as material is itself” (The Culture Industry p. 65). |

EMAIL THIS PAGE
PRINT
RSS









Comments
Right on, Dan! I kept thinking to myself this Christmas "if Christ really is the reason for the season, are we willing to not shop at all and have no gifts under the tree to bring that focus back?" Have you watched Rev. Billy's "What Would Jesus Buy?" If you haven't do yourself a favor and get it off netflix, or from the library. I showed it at our church at the end of November, it helped to put us in the right frame of mind I think.
This year was low-key for us too. It was fun thinking about what traditions we wanted to starting doing. Our first child is 2 and we just had our second on Nov. 27. So this was the first year in a long time that we even got a tree, let alone put up some decorations. After our candle-light service (which was more like a barn-yard service with all the children running around!) we can home and did our gifts. We decided to not do gifts on Christmas (save the toothbrushes and oranges and play dough in the stockings) day so that we could try and save that space for family and reflecting on Christ's birth.
What gifts we did do were simple as well. We decided we wanted another tradition to be giving three gifts, something homemade, something repurposed and something fun (we got L a recycling truck because she loves it when the recycling truck visits our house once a week). It was simpler but it could still be simpler. It's a work in progress but I enjoyed exercising our imaginations around how to make this not about shopping.
Next year I would like to have our main gift be from our family to a local organization that does work we believe in (and somehow go and meet those people and learn about their work, or something). It's an idea I stole from Mark Branson.
The Christmas narrative is about waking up our slumbering imagination to God's creativity and wonderful, unexpected twists in the story (a virgin, unwed, teenager? Shepherds who live out in the fields? God is born among the poor, who live in their own colonized country?). This should inspire our imaginations, send a shock through the system, a rush of blood to the head. Ironically, what Christmas has become is the opposite: a numbing effect, to put us to sleep and turn us into blind consumers.
Wess,
These are good words indeed! I need to check out that film, I've put it on the ol' Netflix que as we speak! Thanks!
Yeah, this economic downturn has had its positives, and this was one of them: to get us to reflect on exactly what your last paragraph says...that's deep...I'm glad we had a chance to do that...I hope we can continue down this road!
I just finished to read your post and want to let you know that you are talented writer.
I found your website perfect for my needs. It contains wonderful and helpful posts. I have read most of garage designsthem and got a lot from them. To me, you are doing the generally i am impressed from this post....the person who create this post it sell websites was a great human..thanks for shared this with us.at work. Carry on this. work at home In the end, I would like to thank you for making garage stylesuch a nice website.
I have you bookmarked your web site to check out the brand new stuff you post. Should you're keen on having a visitor web blog poster please reply and let me know. I will give you unique content in your website, thanks.
-steel scrap traders
I just wish to emphasize the very good work on this weblog, has fantastic views as well as a clear vision of what you might be trying to find.
This is the "spell" of every great thing, feeling or event: Emotions sell, and it will be commercialized in capitalism. As it is with online dating, sms flirt which are based on the feeling of the need of a loved one, as well as the search for schöne frauen. Thanks for the great insight given in your Article! Clara
Interessting to get a deeper look into the christmas industry. We are currently working on our joop online site for Christmas. So these insights will be very helpful, thanks fort that.